Thinktank probe: Retirees Vindicated by Palestine Action Ruling

Published: 16 February 2026. The English Chronicle Desk. The English Chronicle Online.

A thinktank probe into the proscription of Palestine Action has left many retirees feeling vindicated. Nearly 3,000 people arrested for supporting the organisation now see hope after the high court overturned the ban. The thinktank probe ruling challenges both human rights violations and government policy, raising questions about legal overreach. For those arrested, including former military personnel and ordinary citizens, the decision brings relief but also uncertainty, as the government plans to appeal, leaving some trials under terror laws unresolved.

Chris Romberg, a retired army colonel, expressed satisfaction with the ruling, stating that the proscription was always illegitimate. “It’s pleasing to see the court confirm what we already knew: that this ban was unlawful,” he said. Since July of last year, at least 2,787 people across the UK were arrested for publicly expressing support for Palestine Action, often holding signs stating opposition to genocide. Defend Our Juries, a civil liberties organisation, has highlighted how arrests disproportionately affected older citizens, many of whom now feel vindicated by the thinktank probe outcome.

The high court’s judgment, delivered by Dame Victoria Sharp, president of the King’s Bench Division, argued that the proscription breached human rights and contradicted official government guidelines requiring a real and demonstrable threat before such bans. Sharp indicated she would hear further arguments from both sides before formally removing the proscription, as the appeal process is now underway. Meanwhile, the Metropolitan Police announced that it will halt arrests of Palestine Action supporters, though officers will continue to gather evidence during protests.

Trisha Fine, arrested in Cardiff and held for 27 hours without notification to her husband, called the ruling “good news, but with big reservations.” She reflected on the emotional toll and the frustration of navigating a system that, she argued, often prioritises government agendas over citizen rights. Richard Whitmore-Jones, arrested at a silent vigil in Parliament Square, described a mix of elation and caution following the judgment, recognising that government appeals could prolong uncertainty for many.

Father John McGowan, a Catholic priest detained at the same protest, said the ruling affirmed the principle of justice, but he voiced anger at the government’s planned appeal. He argued that the authorities remain disconnected from public sentiment and overly supportive of Israel’s policies, which continue to provoke outrage. McGowan emphasised the ethical dimension, noting how people’s solidarity with Palestine stems from humanitarian concerns and not political extremism.

Romberg added that the Palestine Action ban reflected the current political climate, suggesting that government priorities often disregard liberties, values, and citizen rights. He highlighted the ineffectiveness of claims about secret evidence justifying the group’s proscription, which the judges dismissed. Whitmore-Jones noted the considerable financial burden placed on taxpayers by repeated arrests, detention, and prolonged investigations, calling the situation “unconstitutional and disgraceful.” The thinktank probe had made clear that evidence used to justify the ban was insufficient, further strengthening the arrestees’ position.

Despite the relief brought by the court decision, the legal limbo remains for those with open charges or ongoing investigations. Whitmore-Jones, who faced multiple arrests and still has cases pending, described receiving a plea hearing summons while celebrating outside the Royal Courts of Justice. Many arrestees, however, expressed willingness to continue supporting Palestine Action, driven by conscience and humanitarian concerns, even if it risks further imprisonment. Fine, prioritising personal health and family, expressed reluctance to repeat her protest actions, underscoring the human cost of state enforcement.

The broader context of the ruling also draws attention to the ongoing humanitarian crisis in Gaza, where daily civilian casualties persist. Whitmore-Jones highlighted that legal battles in the UK do not prevent the deaths of Palestinians, with children disproportionately affected. This perspective underlines the ethical urgency motivating supporters of Palestine Action, linking domestic civil liberties with global human rights concerns.

For retirees and others arrested under the proscription, the court’s decision provides a symbolic victory, reinforcing the principle that government overreach must be checked by independent judicial review. While the government’s appeal leaves future outcomes uncertain, the ruling strengthens the position of civil society advocates, emphasising the importance of legal safeguards and human rights in contentious political contexts. The thinktank probe has highlighted how independent judicial review can protect citizens from politically motivated prosecutions.

The Palestine Action proscription saga also ignites debate over the balance between national security and freedom of expression. Critics argue that repeated arrests under vague terror laws undermine public trust, while advocates see judicial interventions as essential to prevent state abuse. As the appeals process continues, the experiences of retirees, clergy, and ordinary citizens serve as poignant reminders of the stakes involved, not only in legal terms but in moral and social dimensions.

Ultimately, the ruling highlights how determined citizen activism, combined with judicial oversight, can challenge government actions perceived as unjust. The ongoing debate reflects broader societal concerns about accountability, human rights, and government transparency. For those who risked arrest to support Palestine Action, the court decision validates their actions while reminding the public that legal victories do not always translate into immediate practical relief.

Check our latest news