Derby delight for Sunderland as Brobbey sinks Newcastle at the death

Published: 22 March 2026. The English Chronicle Desk. The English Chronicle Online.

As recently as Friday morning Eddie Howe talked about some results having bigger consequences than others. This was most definitely one of them for the Magpies. In completing a Premier League double against Newcastle, Régis Le Bris’s promoted Sunderland side surely consigned Howe and his players to one of their most chastening afternoons at St James’ Park. This result will be remembered as a historic derby victory for the visiting fans. Coming four days after their dissection in Barcelona and at the hands of a seriously under-strength Sunderland it is no exaggeration to say that one of Le Bris’s biggest triumphs of an outstanding season represented a disaster for Howe.

Welcome to the region’s capital, declared a banner in the Gallowgate End but it did not take too long until Luke O’Nien’s visit to Tyneside took a turn for the worst. When O’Nien, operating at centre-half in place of the hamstrung Dan Ballard, attempted to play out from the back, he succeeded merely in passing straight to Nick Woltemade. The Germany striker, deployed, once again, in midfield here, responded by nudging the ball to Anthony Gordon whose eventual shot left Le Bris’s second choice goalkeeper, Melker Ellborg, with no hope of a save. With only nine minutes on the clock poor O’Nien had self destructed but, creditably, he and Sunderland galvanised themselves impressively. This early goal added an intense layer of pressure to an already heated derby atmosphere.

When Granit Xhaka’s pass bisected Howe’s backline Aaron Ramsdale did very well to tip Chemsdine Talbi’s swerving shot off its apparently inexorable course towards the top corner. If that was a fine save, Ellborg, had, bar picking the ball out of his net, relatively little to do. Given that two of Le Bris’s first choice defenders, the recently injured Nordi Mukiele and Reinildo, were judged only fit enough for the bench, the visitors were coping with Howe’s attack surprisingly well. Although Anthony Elanga directed a decent chance into the side netting, a Newcastle XI missing the injured Sandro Tonali’s midfield quality still looked perhaps a little traumatised by the memories of last Wednesday night’s 7-2 Champions League thrashing at Barcelona.

Sven Botman and Dan Burn certainly looked slightly nervous in the face of Brian Brobbey’s physicality and ability to hold the ball up. Botman felt sufficiently confident to advance and direct a header against the woodwork at the end of a tight opening half shaded by Newcastle. Early in the second period Botman was forced off with a head injury and replaced by Malick Thiaw. By now Sunderland were improving and Chris Rigg, a boyhood Newcastle fan, forced Ramsdale into a decent save. Then, after pouncing on the fallout from Xhaka’s resultant corner, Ramsdale’s unconvincing punch and Trai Hume’s ensuing half volley, Talbi equalised, stabbing home from close range.

Hume, incidentally, had done well against Elanga in his less preferred left-back role. When Ramsdale was forced to parry a subsequent shot from Noah Sadiki, Newcastle fans grew nervous but Sunderland were starting to tire. Howe’s team had a goal disallowed after Jacob Murphy blocked Ellborg ahead of Thiaw heading a corner home. The moment had arrived for Le Bris to refresh his side and the sight of Enzo Le Fee removing his tracksuit top encouraged the Sunderland fans perched high in the Leazes End. This substitution proved to be a masterstroke in deciding the final outcome of the derby clash.

Le Fee’s convalescence from injury had kept him on the bench for most of the match but now he stepped off it to create the winner for the excellent Brobbey. When Le Fee surged to the byline and cut the ball back for the former Ajax striker, Brobbey was initially denied by Ramsdale but he made no mistake from the rebound. Once the final whistle blew and Le Bris had shaken Eddie Howe’s hand, Le Fee and Brobbey were the first and second players Sunderland’s manager hurried to hug. The scenes of celebration in the away end were a testament to the importance of winning a derby of this magnitude.

The tactical flexibility shown by Régis Le Bris has been a hallmark of Sunderland’s surprising campaign. Even with a depleted squad, the Black Cats displayed a level of organization that frustrated Newcastle’s high-priced stars. Granit Xhaka provided the veteran leadership required in the middle of the park, often dictating the tempo when the game became frantic. His ability to find pockets of space allowed the younger attackers like Talbi and Rigg to flourish. Newcastle, conversely, seemed to lack a clear identity as the match progressed, perhaps still reeling from their European exploits. The physical toll of the Champions League appears to be catching up with Eddie Howe’s squad.

In the aftermath of the match, local pundits have begun to question the depth of the Newcastle bench. While injuries to Tonali and Ballard certainly played a role, the drop in intensity from the Magpies was stark. Sunderland exploited these lapses with clinical efficiency, particularly in the wide areas where Hume and Talbi combined effectively. The atmosphere at St James’ Park turned from hopeful to hostile as the minutes ticked away. Every misplaced pass from a Newcastle player was met with groans from the home faithful. This internal pressure seemed to weigh heavily on the players as they chased a late equalizer that never came.

Brian Brobbey’s performance will likely go down in folklore for the red and white half of the North East. His power and persistence were rewarded with the winning goal in the 90th minute. It was a finish that required both composure and quick reactions after the initial save. For Sunderland, this victory moves them further up the table and cements their status as a team to be feared. For Newcastle, the questions regarding Eddie Howe’s future and the team’s consistency will only grow louder. A derby defeat is never easy to swallow, but losing twice in one season to a local rival is particularly painful.

As the players left the pitch, the contrast in emotions was vivid. The Sunderland players danced in front of their traveling supporters while the Newcastle squad headed straight for the tunnel. This match was a reminder of why football in this region is so deeply cherished. It was a contest filled with drama, errors, and moments of individual brilliance. The tactical battle between Le Bris and Howe was ultimately won by the man who made the right changes at the right time. Sunderland’s ability to stay in the game after conceding early showed a mental toughness that many did not expect.

Looking ahead, Sunderland will hope to carry this momentum into their next series of fixtures. If they can maintain this level of performance, a top-half finish is well within their reach. Newcastle must find a way to reset and recover before their next outing. The loss of Botman to a head injury adds to their mounting defensive concerns. The medical staff will be working overtime to ensure the squad is ready for the challenges that lie ahead. Today, however, the headlines belong to the visitors and their dramatic late winner. It was a derby day that lived up to its billing and left a lasting mark on the Premier League season.

The final statistics told the story of a closely fought encounter that could have gone either way. Newcastle enjoyed more possession, but Sunderland were more clinical with their opportunities. The expected goals metric will likely show a tight margin, reflecting the competitive nature of the play. In the end, it was the desire and grit of the Sunderland players that made the difference. They refused to be intimidated by the setting or the stature of their opponents. This derby win is a significant milestone in the club’s modern history and a platform upon which they can continue to build.

Check our latest news