High Streets Threaten Labour’s Election Prospects

Published: 28 January 2026. The English Chronicle Desk. The English Chronicle Online.

Labour’s political future is under threat unless it successfully tackles Britain’s high streets, experts warn. High street decline has emerged as the most visible indicator of economic and social malaise, shaping voter perceptions across towns and cities. Research conducted by the University of Southampton found residents believe their local high streets have deteriorated more than any other aspect of their communities in the past decade, reflecting a profound sense of place-based frustration. The polling, conducted by YouGov, showed improving high streets ranks just behind healthcare and crime reduction as a top local priority for voters.

The findings underline that Reform UK supporters are particularly vocal about decline in their areas, highlighting widespread resentment toward Westminster. Labour MPs acknowledge the symbolism of high streets as a measure of community prosperity, with businesses increasingly critical of rising rates and inflationary pressures. In response, the government recently introduced a business rates discount for pubs and announced a forthcoming “high street strategy” to rejuvenate town centres. Treasury minister Dan Tomlinson emphasised the challenges posed by changing consumer behaviour, including online shopping and hybrid working patterns, which continue to strain traditional retail models.

Data analysis by the Guardian reveals a stark shift: between 2019 and 2025, Britain lost at least 8,000 retail outlets. Traditional shops such as clothing stores, department stores, and florists have steadily disappeared, while restaurants, discount shops, and vape retailers have expanded. The pandemic accelerated online shopping, with the Office for National Statistics reporting that 28% of all retail transactions took place online by October 2025, up from 19% in 2019.

High street restaurants surged from just over 17,000 to 25,000 outlets as public appetite for dining out returned after lockdowns. Service-oriented businesses, including hair salons and tattoo studios, also capitalised on vacant premises, increasing by 17% and 20%, respectively. Similarly, the popularity of vaping among younger adults drove a 38% rise in specialist e-cigarette shops, while bargain stores increased by 41% as cost-conscious consumers sought affordability in the wake of the cost of living crisis.

Even some traditional retailers demonstrated resilience. Bookshops saw a near 20% increase despite Amazon’s dominance. Conversely, department stores fell to slightly above 1,000 from 1,700 six years ago. Betting shops and opticians also reduced their footprint, with betting outlets falling over 20% and opticians by 12%. Florists and stationers experienced notable declines, by 24% and 23% respectively, highlighting the erosion of historic high street staples. Nightclubs dropped almost 20%, contrasting sharply with a 46% growth in gyms driven by major chains such as PureGym and The Gym Group.

The reduction of basic amenities further illustrates high street decline. Public toilets dropped by 20%, reflecting council budget cuts, while cash machines decreased from 4,380 to 2,573 as digital payments dominate. Labour MP Leigh Ingham described this decline as “the heritage of 14 years of austerity” and advocates legislation allowing councils to reclaim vacant shops for community projects. Ingham emphasised the importance of local input, arguing change is most effective when communities lead initiatives rather than having decisions imposed externally.

Prof Will Jennings, who oversaw the Southampton research, stressed that Labour’s electoral prospects depend on addressing high street decline. “Voters perceive that Westminster ignores regional needs, creating deep resentment toward central government,” he said. Surveys from YouGov highlight collapsing local pride between September 2022 and July 2024, driven by concerns about healthcare, retail closures, crime, and opportunities for youth. Despite partial recovery under Labour last year, high street deterioration remains the most pressing issue residents perceive as worsening over the past decade.

In response, the government launched a £5 billion, ten-year “pride in place” programme, targeting 250 areas across England, Scotland, and Wales, offering up to £20 million per location for locally led regeneration projects. Culture Secretary Lisa Nandy also revealed that the UK’s first “town of culture” will be named in 2026. However, business groups stress regeneration requires practical support to succeed. Tina McKenzie, policy chair at the Federation of Small Businesses, warned that costs related to staffing, energy, and business rates could stall recovery. She noted that maintaining a diverse mix of retailers is essential to preserve footfall and meet evolving consumer demand.

Analysis of Land Registry data shows nearly one-fifth of freeholds in England and Wales shopping areas are held by real estate companies, while less than 2% are owned by retailers themselves. Ninety-four retail districts are dominated by a single landowner or council, posing additional challenges for local regeneration. Experts argue that revitalising high streets is not only a political necessity for Labour but crucial for sustaining community identity, jobs, and local pride. The research underscores that high streets remain a barometer for social cohesion, demonstrating that political fortunes are now tightly intertwined with the health of town centres.

Without effective intervention, Labour risks being swept aside in the next general election, as voters increasingly judge politicians on tangible improvements to their local high streets. Reviving these areas will require coordinated policy, investment, and community engagement to reverse decline and ensure that high streets once again serve as the heart of Britain’s towns and cities. The focus on high streets is no longer simply about commerce; it reflects broader concerns about economic vitality, social infrastructure, and national cohesion, making it a defining issue for political strategy in the coming years.

Check our latest news