Police Watchdog Calls for End to Recording Non-Crime Hate Incidents

Published: 10 September 2025 | The English Chronicle Online

The chief inspector of constabulary has called for an end to the recording and investigation of non-crime hate incidents (NCHIs), arguing that the practice consumes police resources while generating public controversy.

Sir Andy Cooke, who leads HM Inspectorate of Constabulary and Fire and Rescue Services, said intelligence could be gathered through alternative methods that would reduce public concern and simplify policing. “I’m a firm believer that non-crime hate incidents are no longer required,” he said, adding that the current approach draws disproportionate criticism despite taking up a minuscule amount of police time.

NCHIs are recorded by forces to monitor community tensions and prevent potential trouble. However, some critics, particularly on the political right, see the practice as a threat to free speech. A review of the policy is underway at the College of Policing, which sets national standards for law enforcement, though the body has provided few further details.

The debate over online conduct and policing continues to be contentious. Last week, Father Ted writer Graham Linehan was arrested under the Public Order Act for allegedly inciting violence via social media posts on transgender issues, claims he denies. Linehan was detained by five armed officers upon arriving at Heathrow Airport, prompting widespread discussion about the appropriateness of police intervention.

Cooke acknowledged the public scrutiny surrounding the arrest, stressing that he was not criticising the Metropolitan Police or the officers involved. “Was it a great public optic? No, it wasn’t,” he said, noting that high-profile incidents like this can distract from the wider work of law enforcement. He added that the police are often placed in difficult positions by current legislation, and called for a review of policies governing online and non-crime incidents.

Launching the inspectorate’s annual state of policing report, Cooke emphasised the need for comprehensive reform and increased government funding. “The reforms require substantial upfront investment, and sustained commitment to succeed. They must be sufficiently funded,” he said.

The report highlighted ongoing challenges across forces in England and Wales. Of the graded judgments, 26% were rated as “requires improvement” and 6% as “inadequate.” Many forces were found to struggle with responding to the public, investigating crime, and protecting vulnerable people. While resource limitations contribute to these issues, the inspectorate noted that leadership, efficiency, and effectiveness could be improved even within existing budgets.

Cooke concluded that reforms to legislation, policy, and funding are essential to ensure that police can focus on serious criminality while gathering intelligence efficiently, without becoming embroiled in controversy over non-crime incidents.