M&S Boss Slates Food Price Caps as ‘Preposterous’

Published: 20 May 2026. The English Chronicle Desk. The English Chronicle Online.

The high street giant Marks and Spencer has hit back hard against government proposals regarding voluntary price caps on essential grocery items. The retail boss Stuart Machin described the potential policy as completely preposterous during a recent industry address. Instead of intervening in commercial pricing, Machin argued that ministers should focus on reducing heavy tax and regulatory burdens. The chief executive stressed that the high street already operates on incredibly slim margins for staple products. He revealed that the retailer actually loses money on daily essentials like milk, bread, and baked beans. Furthermore, items like sugar and eggs yield minimal profits despite high demand from hard-pressed British shoppers. Machin firmly believes that politicians should avoid trying to manage private businesses from Whitehall offices. He suggested that a deeper understanding of commercial realities would serve the public far better. The government could provide meaningful support by easing the financial pressures within its direct control.

The controversy emerged after officials suggested supermarkets cap prices for basic items like butter and bread. In return, the government offered to ease certain regulations on packaging and healthy food initiatives. However, the retail sector views this compromise as an inadequate solution to much larger economic problems. Machin noted that British shops currently face a triple whammy of severe financial headwinds today. Retailers are battling increased corporate taxation, a growing regulatory burden, and ongoing global conflicts overseas. Ministers have the power to relieve these intense pressures to help businesses invest and grow. A major concern for the high street is the dramatic rise in recent government taxation. The new packaging levy alone has introduced forty million pounds in additional corporate costs recently. Analysts expect an extra ten million pounds will hit the business before the year ends.

Furthermore, recent changes to national insurance contributions have added fifty million pounds to internal costs. This financial burden could double when factoring in the increased costs passed down by suppliers. Machin warned that these rising regulatory costs and taxes directly impact employment opportunities across Britain. The extra financial pressure puts a significant dampener on the company’s ability to hire staff. Fortunately, the business anticipated many of these taxes and planned cost-cutting measures to offset them. However, unexpected geopolitical conflicts in the Middle East have caused further disruption for global supply chains. Some international suppliers have already demanded higher prices, adding several million pounds to company costs. Despite these challenges, the retailer has managed to absorb or offset most of these unexpected expenses.

The chief executive shared these insights while announcing major investments in technology and new stores. The business plans to open eighteen new food halls across the country very soon. This ambitious expansion follows annual financial results that revealed a massive hit to recent corporate profits. A devastating cyber-attack last Easter managed to knock nearly a quarter off the company’s profits. Machin described the upcoming financial year as one of the most important in company history. The retailer plans to introduce automated distribution centres and refurbish its traditional clothing departments. Additionally, the team will use advanced artificial intelligence to sharpen marketing and product sourcing. The next three years will be absolutely critical as the business invests heavily for growth.

The company chairman Archie Norman stated it is time to shake dust off their heels. He assured investors that product availability issues caused by the cyber incident are finally tapering off. New seasonal clothing and home ranges are currently resonating exceptionally well with British consumers today. The bold investment pledge arrived as underlying profits slumped by nearly twenty-four percent this year. Total underlying profits dropped to six hundred and seventy-one million pounds recently. Meanwhile, overall group sales rose by just under two percent to over fourteen billion pounds. This slow sales growth occurred despite widespread national inflation running at over three percent recently. Profits were severely dragged down by over one hundred and thirty million pounds in cyber costs.

While food sales rose by seven percent, fashion and homeware departments suffered a significant decline. International sales also dropped by over seven percent as the digital fallout continued to hit operations. Retail analysts warned that the future profit outlook appears worse than initial market expectations suggested. The company stated that the coming year will face higher fuel and freight costs. Continued government tax levies and regulatory hurdles will also weigh heavily on future financial performance. Financial experts at Jefferies noted the business is predicting lower annual profits than previously expected. The investment firm projected profits around eight hundred and seventy-six million pounds for next year. This figure sits well below the original city consensus of nine hundred and sixty-four million.

The chief financial officer Alison Dolan explained that stock flow was materially disrupted this year. The digital attack put intense pressure on the supply chain and reduced shelf availability everywhere. Consequently, the retailer was left with excess stock that required heavy discounting to clear out. Despite these supply chain woes, the food division delivered an incredibly strong performance this year. The grocery department helped the brand achieve its highest market share in company history recently. The grocery market share reached over four percent, proving the enduring popularity of the brand. This figure rises further when including grocery sales made through the online joint venture Ocado.

The retailer sold over one billion pounds worth of goods via the internet channel. This milestone helped the online delivery service return to profitability after several years of losses. Ocado posted an encouraging operating profit of over fifteen million pounds for the financial year. Machin praised the online operation for improving its overall customer efficiency and delivery logistics. However, he concluded that much more work remains before committing to further capital investment. The brand must navigate a challenging economic landscape while balancing digital recovery and physical expansion. British shoppers will watch closely to see how the retailer manages prices in store aisles. The debate over supermarket pricing and government intervention looks set to continue for months.

Check our latest news