Families of children with special educational needs and disabilities in England could receive new opportunities to challenge decisions about their children’s school support under changes being considered by the government. The proposed measures may introduce independent appeal routes through the Local Government and Social Care Ombudsman or specially appointed review panels, following growing criticism that the government’s planned overhaul of special needs education could weaken parents’ existing legal protections.
The possible changes come amid mounting pressure from parents, campaigners and organisations representing children with special educational needs and disabilities, commonly known as SEND. They have raised concerns that the proposed reforms could leave families with fewer effective ways to challenge schools or local authorities when children do not receive the educational support, specialist assistance or therapy they require.
Education Secretary Lucy Powell has indicated that the government is examining the issue as part of its wider reform programme. Responding to concerns raised by MPs, Powell encouraged them to wait for further details and suggested that changes to the appeals process were an important part of the government’s ongoing work.
She said the government wanted to ensure that appropriate mechanisms were available to families, with clear accountability and a fair opportunity to resolve disagreements. Her comments have raised expectations that ministers may reconsider some of the most controversial aspects of the proposed reforms before final legislation is introduced.
People involved in discussions with policymakers have indicated that two possible independent appeal routes are under consideration. Both would aim to provide families with a forum to challenge decisions when they believe the support offered by a school is insufficient or unsuitable for their child’s needs.
The first option would involve extending the role of the Local Government and Social Care Ombudsman, which already investigates complaints involving local authorities, including certain issues relating to SEND provision and school transport. Under this proposal, parents could have an independent body examine complaints about the support provided by schools, rather than being required to rely entirely on the institution involved in the dispute.
The second option would establish independent review panels, potentially modelled on existing arrangements for challenging school exclusion decisions. These panels can examine exclusion cases and have the authority to overturn certain decisions. They are appointed by local authorities and may include a clerk and up to five experts who have no direct connection with the school concerned.
A similar approach for SEND disputes could provide parents with an additional level of scrutiny when they believe a school has failed to provide appropriate assistance. However, the effectiveness of either proposal would depend on the independence of the decision-makers, their understanding of special educational needs and whether their decisions could lead to meaningful action within a reasonable period.
The debate has emerged from the government’s SEND reform white paper, published in February under the leadership of former education secretary Bridget Phillipson. The document proposed major changes to the way special educational support is organised and funded across England.
A central element of the proposed reforms is a move away from the widespread use of Education, Health and Care Plans, known as EHCPs, towards a new system of support managed by schools. The proposed Individual Support Plans, or ISPs, would establish different levels of assistance for children according to their needs.
EHCPs currently provide a formal framework setting out the educational, health and care support that a child or young person requires. They can play a particularly important role for families whose children have complex needs and require coordinated assistance from schools, local authorities and specialist services.
Under the existing system, parents who disagree with decisions concerning an EHCP can appeal to an independent First-tier SEND Tribunal. This provides a formal route for resolving disputes over assessments, the contents of plans and the educational provision children should receive.
However, the government’s proposed changes would restrict the role of the tribunal in disputes involving the new Individual Support Plans. Instead, complaints about the support offered through ISPs would largely be handled by the child’s school. This has become one of the most controversial parts of the reform programme because parents and campaigners fear that schools could effectively be placed in a position where they are responsible for reviewing complaints about their own decisions.
Critics argue that such an arrangement would create an imbalance between families and educational institutions. Parents who believe their children are being denied appropriate support may find it difficult to challenge decisions if the final authority rests with the same school responsible for providing that assistance.
Jane Harris, chief executive of the charity Speech and Language UK, said children with speech and language difficulties and their families had experienced significant challenges for many years. She stressed that any replacement appeals system must give parents a genuinely independent, efficient and effective way to challenge decisions and secure the education and therapy their children need.
Harris also warned against allowing schools to become responsible for making final decisions on complaints about their own provision. In her view, such an arrangement could weaken parents’ confidence and damage relationships between families and the schools responsible for supporting children.
She argued that whichever organisation ultimately handles appeals must have appropriate expertise and sufficient independence. Its decisions should also carry meaningful authority and result in timely action. Without those safeguards, she warned, children could remain at risk of missing essential educational and therapeutic support.
Madeleine Cassidy, chief executive of the charity Independent Provider of Special Education Advice, known as Ipsea, also welcomed indications that ministers were considering alternative appeal arrangements. She described the government’s willingness to examine additional routes as encouraging, given the level of concern among parents and carers.
Ipsea has long argued that the Local Government and Social Care Ombudsman’s responsibilities should be extended to cover schools, allowing complaints about SEND support to be investigated independently. Cassidy said the proposed reduction in the SEND tribunal’s powers and families’ opportunities to challenge decisions had been a major source of anxiety.
However, she cautioned that stronger complaints procedures must not replace or weaken enforceable legal rights. An independent complaints mechanism may help resolve disputes, but it would not necessarily provide the same protection as a legal right that can be enforced through a tribunal.
That distinction is central to the debate. Parents want a system that resolves problems quickly, but they also need confidence that schools and public authorities can be held accountable when they fail to provide the support required by law. Campaigners fear that a system relying mainly on complaints procedures could leave families with fewer effective remedies, even if additional review arrangements are introduced.
The Department for Education has said it understands parents’ concerns and recognises the importance of clear routes for resolving disputes. A spokesperson said the government was considering feedback received through consultation and engagement events and that it would be inappropriate to announce final decisions before the process had been completed.
The department also emphasised its investment in schools to improve inclusion and develop a system in which children receive appropriate support in their local communities without families having to fight for it.
Powell faced further questions about the issue this month when she appeared before Parliament’s Education Select Committee. Labour MP Mark Sewards, who represents Leeds South West and Morley, raised concerns that parents feared losing their existing rights of appeal under the proposed reforms.
The education secretary acknowledged that SEND policy was complex and said the government was determined to get the details right during the final stages of the process. She emphasised the need for a level playing field for families as well as accountability throughout the system.
The urgency of the debate is underlined by the growing pressure on the existing tribunal system. Official figures released by the government in October showed that the average waiting time for a final oral hearing at the SEND tribunal had exceeded 18 months. An appeal lodged at the time of the announcement could therefore wait until May 2028 to reach a final hearing.
The tribunal is also facing record demand. Around 8,800 appeals were lodged in the three months to June, while its backlog increased to approximately 18,000 cases. That represented a 31 per cent rise compared with 2025.
The figures highlight the difficulties facing families who already struggle to secure suitable educational support. Long waiting periods can leave children without the assistance their parents believe they need, while families face prolonged uncertainty over their children’s education and development.
The government’s challenge is therefore not simply to introduce alternative appeal arrangements but to ensure that the wider SEND system becomes more accessible, responsive and reliable. Reducing delays, improving school-level support and preserving meaningful legal protections will all be important if the reforms are to gain public confidence.
The government’s bill and its formal response to the consultation on the SEND white paper are not expected until early next year. Until then, parents, campaigners, schools and local authorities will be watching closely to see whether ministers introduce stronger independent safeguards.
For families, the outcome could have lasting consequences. A successful reform would need to ensure that children receive appropriate support without unnecessary delays and that parents can challenge decisions through a process they trust. The government has acknowledged the importance of accountability, but the final legislation will determine whether the proposed changes provide families with stronger protection or leave them facing new obstacles when seeking help for their children.

























































































