Efforts to develop technologies capable of removing carbon dioxide directly from the atmosphere have gained renewed attention at the United Nations climate conference in Antalya, Turkey, as scientists, industry representatives and climate campaigners debate how the world could reverse the effects of global warming. Supporters of carbon dioxide removal (CDR) are pressing governments to recognise the technology in the final agreement of COP31, arguing that reducing greenhouse gas emissions alone may no longer be sufficient to restore global temperatures to internationally agreed limits.
The renewed campaign comes as the world faces growing concerns about exceeding the 1.5-degree Celsius temperature threshold established under the Paris climate agreement. Scientists and international organisations have repeatedly warned that continued greenhouse gas emissions could push global temperatures beyond this level, increasing the frequency and intensity of extreme weather events, including heatwaves, floods, droughts and destructive storms.
Against this background, advocates of carbon removal believe the international community must develop a coordinated strategy to extract significant quantities of carbon dioxide from the atmosphere and store it for extended periods. They argue that such measures could eventually help bring global temperatures down after an anticipated period of temperature overshoot.
At COP31, a group of carbon removal supporters has established a pavilion called Think Negative, where researchers, technology companies and campaigners are discussing the potential for expanding carbon removal operations worldwide. Their objective is to persuade governments to include CDR in the conference’s final outcome and establish an international framework capable of coordinating future projects.
The proposal has attracted attention because carbon removal has historically received less political and financial support than conventional emissions reduction programmes. Advocates now want governments to recognise it as an essential component of long-term climate policy rather than treating it as a distant technological possibility.
Göker Avci, a decarbonisation strategist at CDR Türkiye, said campaigners had spent an entire year attempting to bring carbon dioxide removal into the COP31 agenda. According to Avci, discussions with the conference presidency had helped increase awareness of the technology’s potential, and supporters were now seeking its inclusion in the final decision.
The push has gained additional significance because carbon capture and storage (CCS), a related but different technology, has also become more prominent at this year’s climate negotiations. According to the Center for International Environmental Law, approximately 700 lobbyists representing interests associated with carbon capture and storage are attending COP31. Their presence exceeds the combined representation of the 50 smallest national delegations at the conference.
The distinction between CDR and CCS is important because the two approaches address carbon emissions at different stages. Carbon dioxide removal involves taking greenhouse gases that are already present in the atmosphere and storing them in underground geological formations, oceans or other suitable materials. Carbon capture and storage, by contrast, generally captures carbon dioxide directly from industrial facilities or other emission sources before it enters the atmosphere.
Although both approaches involve storing carbon, their environmental implications, costs and potential contributions to climate targets remain subjects of considerable debate.
On Friday, both carbon capture and carbon dioxide removal appeared in a draft text intended to inform the basis of the final agreement at COP31. The development represented a significant moment for supporters who have long argued that carbon removal should receive greater attention in international climate negotiations.
The urgency surrounding the issue has increased following warnings that the world is heading towards a prolonged period of temperature overshoot. The United Nations has acknowledged that global temperatures are likely to exceed the 1.5-degree threshold, at least temporarily, because countries have not reduced greenhouse gas emissions quickly enough.
The consequences could be severe. Higher temperatures are associated with more intense heatwaves, changing rainfall patterns, prolonged droughts, rising sea levels and increased pressure on agriculture and water supplies. Vulnerable communities, particularly those in developing countries, face some of the greatest risks because they often have fewer financial and technological resources to prepare for climate-related disasters.
Supporters of CDR argue that removing carbon dioxide from the atmosphere could eventually help address the accumulated greenhouse gases responsible for rising global temperatures. They point out that international climate models have included some form of carbon removal for decades, although practical implementation has remained limited.
Injy Johnstone, a net-zero expert at the Max Planck Institute, said carbon removal had been largely absent from public discussions despite its presence in long-term climate projections. She argued that the technology would be necessary to balance emissions that cannot immediately be eliminated and help the world recover from temperature overshoot.
Johnstone also suggested that carbon removal should not depend entirely on individual entrepreneurs and private companies. Instead, she called for a more coordinated international approach, including procedures and institutions capable of supporting large-scale implementation.
Different methods are being considered for removing carbon dioxide. One approach involves direct air capture, in which specialised machines extract carbon dioxide from the surrounding atmosphere. Another involves crushing certain types of rocks to accelerate natural chemical processes that permanently bind carbon. Nature-based approaches, including forest restoration, mangrove protection and expanded vegetation cover, can also absorb and store substantial quantities of carbon.
However, the current scale of carbon removal remains far below what would be required to reverse global warming significantly.
According to the third edition of the State of Carbon Dioxide Removal report, approximately two billion tonnes of carbon dioxide are removed annually through various methods, with the overwhelming majority coming from conventional land-based activities such as reforestation. Technological direct air capture, meanwhile, has removed only around two million tonnes.
The difference highlights the enormous gap between existing capabilities and the ambitions being discussed at COP31. Although direct air capture has attracted considerable investment and scientific interest, several leading companies have struggled to meet their targets and maintain financial stability. Limited investor funding has also restricted the development of new projects, particularly as substantial financial resources are being directed towards rapidly expanding industries such as artificial intelligence.
Despite these difficulties, the long-term requirements remain substantial. A recent United Nations Environment Programme assessment estimated that approximately 320 billion tonnes of carbon dioxide would need to be removed during this century to return global warming below 1.5 degrees Celsius.
Meeting such an ambitious target would require unprecedented technological development, international investment, regulatory cooperation and large-scale infrastructure. It would also require governments to determine how carbon removal projects should be monitored, financed and evaluated to ensure that claimed environmental benefits are genuine.
Nevertheless, the growing enthusiasm surrounding CDR has raised serious concerns among environmental organisations and climate campaigners. Critics warn that excessive reliance on future carbon removal technologies could weaken immediate efforts to reduce fossil fuel consumption. They argue that governments and companies might continue releasing greenhouse gases if they believe future technologies will eventually remove the pollution.
Rachel Kennerley, a carbon capture campaigner at the Center for International Environmental Law, stressed that reducing emissions must remain the primary priority.
She warned against assuming that technological solutions developed in the future would automatically be capable of removing the carbon dioxide released today. According to Kennerley, the expectation of exceeding temperature limits and subsequently reversing the damage risks normalising an uncertain climate strategy.
Environmental concerns also extend to the potential physical impact of large-scale carbon removal operations. Removing hundreds of billions of tonnes of carbon dioxide could require extensive land use, substantial energy supplies and significant infrastructure. Some approaches could also affect water resources, agricultural production, natural ecosystems and ocean environments.
Critics question whether the environmental costs of deploying these technologies on an enormous scale could create additional problems, particularly if projects are implemented without sufficient safeguards.
Kennerley has also criticised carbon capture and storage, arguing that major oil and gas companies could use the technology to maintain fossil fuel operations rather than accelerate the transition towards cleaner energy. In her view, both CCS and CDR risk diverting political attention from the immediate need to reduce greenhouse gas emissions.
She has argued that the world should minimise any period of temperature overshoot by rapidly reducing fossil fuel consumption, while protecting and restoring forests to gradually absorb excess carbon dioxide over many generations.
Supporters of carbon removal, however, believe the scale of the climate emergency makes the technology unavoidable. They argue that even ambitious emissions reduction measures may not be sufficient to eliminate all greenhouse gases already accumulated in the atmosphere or address emissions from industries that remain difficult to decarbonise.
Johnstone described carbon removal as an essential tool and called for its development on a scale comparable to the global energy industry. Her position reflects the growing belief among some climate experts that future climate strategies will require a combination of emissions reduction, technological innovation and natural carbon absorption.
The debate at COP31 therefore highlights a fundamental challenge facing international climate policy: how to balance immediate action against long-term technological possibilities. While carbon removal could eventually become an important part of global climate solutions, its current capacity, financial limitations and environmental implications remain significant obstacles.
As negotiations continue in Antalya, the inclusion of CDR in the conference’s final agreement could represent an important political development. However, recognition alone will not guarantee that the technology can deliver the scale of carbon removal required.
Ultimately, the success of any future strategy will depend on whether governments can establish credible safeguards, mobilise long-term investment and ensure that carbon removal complements rather than replaces emissions reduction. With global temperatures continuing to rise and vulnerable communities facing increasingly severe climate impacts, the international community must determine whether these emerging technologies can become practical solutions without delaying the urgent action required today.



























































































